Posts

How To Choose A Piano Teacher – Part 2: The Studio

Choose the right piano teacher by looking at these simple features at their studio

 

How to Choose a Music School for your child

 

Are you considering enrolling your child (or yourself) in piano lessons? Then this is the blog series for you.

In this two-part series, we’re discussing how to choose a piano teacher, with a focus on what to look for, what you can compromise on (if absolutely necessary), and what’s non-negotiable.

Last week, we discussed what to look for in the teacher themselves. If you haven’t read that post yet, you can find it here. As a refresher, when you choose a piano teacher, you should look for the following things:

  • University qualifications (preferably B.Mus. majoring in performance)
  • AMEB qualifications (A.Mus. or L.Mus – non-negotiable)
  • Experience (someone who’s taught for 5+ years)
  • Personality (someone you “click” with)

Today, let’s look at what you should look for in the teacher’s piano studio

Cost

Generally speaking, a piano teacher’s qualifications and experience determines how much they charge for lessons. Prices range from $40 to $150 an hour; $80 an hour is the average.

Piano lessons are a big investment for any family. So it’s important to ensure you get what you pay for. $80 an hour should get you a fully-qualified teacher with a B.Mus. (majoring in performance), an A.Mus. or L.Mus. from a music examination board, and at least 10 years’ teaching experience.

Some music schools charge $80 per hour, but their teachers are not fully-qualified. The extra money goes to the school, not the teacher. As I said, if you’re going to pay that sort of money, you want to get your money’s worth. (If you do choose to go with a less-qualified teacher due to financial pressures, be sure you’re paying a less-qualified wage.)

So how do you make sure you’re getting what you pay for with a fully-qualified teacher? As I said in my last post, don’t be afraid to ask about a teacher’s experience and qualifications. You’re paying for their services, so you deserve to know.

[Tweet “Some music schools charge $80 per hour, but their teachers are not fully-qualified #piano”]

 

Location

A common-sense consideration, but an important one: try to find a local teacher located no more than 20 to 30 minutes away. While you and your child may initially be enthusiastic about lessons at the end of an hour’s drive, this enthusiasm probably won’t last.

But be sure you do travel to the teacher. While some teachers will come to you, your child (or you) will be disadvantaged by learning to play only on the piano in your home. This is especially true when it comes to recitals or exams, as a student who has only ever played on one instrument will struggle to adapt to a foreign instrument, especially under pressure.

[Tweet “A student who has only ever played on one #piano will struggle to adapt to a foreign instrument”]

Which leads us onto our next point…

Instrument

Always choose a teacher who teaches their students on a quality acoustic piano. This is non-negotiable. Your child (or you) cannot learn to play the piano properly on an electronic keyboard. While a keyboard is an acceptable instrument for beginners practicing at home, you should always learn on an acoustic piano.

(To learn more about acoustic pianos vs. electronic keyboards, check out this post.)

Studio Policy

It might seem a funny thing to look for, but it’s important to choose a piano teacher with a thorough studio policy.

A studio policy indicates that a teacher is experienced and successful, and runs their studio professionally. The policy will protect them, but it will also protect you as a client.

Look for elements in their policy that discuss:

  • Trial lessons (you don’t want to be locked into a term of lessons without having a trial first)
  • How lessons are charged (e.g. weekly, monthly, per term, or annually) and whether late fees apply
  • Policies for make-up lessons and cancellations
  • Provision of sheet music (photocopying sheet music is illegal)

This will give you a good idea of the piano teacher’s level of professionalism, experience, and ethics.

Exams

While some music schools have their own exam system, any qualifications your child (or you) obtain will not be recognised elsewhere. If piano exams are important to you, then be sure to choose a teacher who prepares students for music board exams with either AMEB, ABRSM, or Trinity.

Your teacher should also have a transcript of their students’ past exam results. Feel free to ask them to show this to you.

[Tweet “Some schools have their own exams, any qualifications obtain will not be recognised elsewhere”]

 

Performance Opportunities

I’m a big believer in providing students with performance opportunities. Performing helps your playing and confidence blossom. Ask if your piano teacher holds recitals for students, or provides them with other opportunities to perform. You can also check to see if there are photos or – better yet – videos of their students performing on their website or YouTube/Vimeo channel.

Making The Choice

Do you feel prepared to make the right choice when it comes to choosing a piano teacher and piano studio for your child (or you)?

When evaluating a piano studio, remember:

  • Make sure you get what you pay for in terms of teacher experience
  • Find a teacher near you
  • Always choose a teacher who teaches on an acoustic piano
  • Make sure there’s a studio policy to protect them and you
  • Look for a teacher who teaches AMEB, ABRSM, or Trinity
  • Make sure the studio offers performance opportunities to their students

If you have any questions or comments about this post, then please share them in the comments below. And if you enjoyed this article, don’t forget to share it on Facebook so your friends can learn how to choose a piano teacher, too!

[shareaholic app=”share_buttons” id=”7262185″]

 

Looking For A Piano Teacher?

I know a good one 😉 Read more about learning the piano with Le Piano Academy here.

 

 

What’s the Difference? AMEB Pianoforte vs. AMEB Piano for Leisure

Everything you should know about the AMEB’s two main piano syllabuses

 

AMEB Classical Piano vs. AMEB Piano for Leisure

 

If you’re a piano student, or the parent of a student, then you’ll undoubtedly encounter the AMEB at some time during your piano career. Many piano teachers, myself included, choose to teach their students the AMEB piano syllabus.

Although there are other music examination boards, such as ABRSM and Trinity, I prefer the AMEB syllabus because the AMEB has formal links to Australian universities, they help write the HSC music syllabus, and they have a larger repertoire for students to choose from and be examined on.

Nowadays, the AMEB offers several piano examination options. Before you or your child take a piano exam, it’s important to educate yourself on the differences between each option, and the pros and cons of choosing each.

(Got questions or comments? Share them in the comments below and I’ll be sure to get back to you.)

The AMEB Piano Courses

In addition to their traditional Pianoforte syllabus, the AMEB now has two other piano/keyboard courses: AMEB Piano for Leisure, and AMEB Contemporary Popular Music (Keyboard). Of these three courses, the original Pianoforte and the more recent Piano for Leisure are the most popular choice for piano students to study.

But what’s the difference between the two? We’ll compare by looking at the Grade 5 syllabus for each of them.

Grade 5 Pianoforte vs. Grade 5 Piano for Leisure

At a glance, the AMEB Pianoforte and Piano for Leisure syllabuses seem quite comparable. Both examine technical work (such as scales and arpeggios), piano pieces, and general music and piano knowledge. For Pianoforte, students are examined on both aural and sight-reading skills, while Piano for Leisure students are examined on only one of the two, a choice they are able to make. Importantly, the standard/difficulty of the pieces in both syllabuses is the same.

However, while the two courses may be almost identical on the surface, a closer look reveals that they are ultimately very different.

A Closer Look

Here’s a breakdown of how the grade 5 AMEB Pianoforte and Piano for Leisure courses are examined.

Pianoforte Piano for Leisure
Technical 37 scales (legato & staccato) 13 scales (legato only)
Pieces 4 list pieces, 2 extra pieces 3 pieces
Sight-reading Always examined Optional (can choose aural instead)
Aural Always examined Optional (can choose sight-reading instead)
General Knowledge Always examined Always examined

As you can see, a piano student’s workload is 50-70% less if they sit the Piano for Leisure exam rather than Pianoforte.

The Pros and Cons of Choosing the Pianoforte Syllabus

While each AMEB piano course has its own advantages, each has its own disadvantages, too.

AMEB Pianoforte students benefit from a more thorough examination, with more pieces and more scales. Pianoforte is the better choice if you wish to apply for a music scholarship at a high school, and if you’re interested in studying piano at university level, Pianoforte gives you a much more solid foundation. The syllabus also goes beyond Grade 8 to A.Mus and L.Mus.

The only real disadvantage of studying Pianoforte is that the set repertoire is classical. However, this is barely a disadvantage, as students can choose to be examined on non-classical repertoire from the Piano for Leisure syllabus as their extra list pieces.

The Pros and Cons of Taking Piano for Leisure

The greatest advantage to choosing the AMEB Piano for Leisure course over Pianoforte is that it involves less preparation and is therefore ideal for less serious music students – for instance, those who have many other extracurricular commitments and do not have the time to devote to the practice required when preparing for a Pianoforte exam. Piano for Leisure also includes a wider range of music genres, including film, popular, and jazz music.

The Le Piano Academy Approach

Many piano teachers only teach for exams. But that means that a student will only be learning three pieces a year. If you’re only going to learn three pieces a year, you really shouldn’t be playing the piano.

At Le Piano Academy, my number one priority is to ensure that my students receive a thorough musical education. Learning to play the piano isn’t all about taking exams – or at least, it shouldn’t be. I don’t force my students to take exams, and I leave the choice of which AMEB syllabus they take up to them.

Every year, my students and I plan out what they will learn at the beginning of the year. We allocate pieces not only for exams, but also for their recital. The recital is just as important (maybe more) as exams, as it gives students the chance to play in front of others, including their parents, grandparents, and family.

Thorough Piano Education

For students who are planning on taking exams, I like to ensure that they still study a varied and thorough curriculum.

For Pianoforte students, I always pick popular or jazz music pieces for them to learn from the Piano for Leisure syllabus as well, because no one wants to play only classical music all the time! If they wish, my students can use these pieces as extra lists.

When my students choose Piano for Leisure, I still make sure they do the Pianoforte scale syllabus, as more scales mean better technique, and better technique will mean that they play the Piano for Leisure pieces more easily. I also still teach them both aural and sight-reading skills, because while they may only be tested on one, both are very important.

The Bottom Line

So there you have it – AMEB Pianoforte vs. Piano for Leisure.

While the AMEB might argue that Piano for Leisure isn’t a “lesser alternative”, it’s quite clear that it involves a lot less work and preparation than Pianoforte. However, this isn’t necessarily a bad thing in and of itself. Instead, your choice of AMEB curriculum should be based on your personal circumstances, preferences, and musical goals.

Your Say

Have you taken AMEB exams? Which did you sit, and what did you like/dislike about it? Let me know in the comments below!

For any piano teachers reading this, which syllabus do you teach? Do you still teach your students aural and sight-reading skills, and extra scales, when you teach the Piano for Leisure course? Share your approach in the comments below.

[shareaholic app=”share_buttons” id=”7262185″]